Small Audiences Buy Faster (Stop Playing Big)

Why you should stay small and nurture a small audience rather than going big

For the longest time, I believed I needed a big audience to make money.

Everywhere I looked, creators were chasing numbers—10,000 subscribers, 100K followers, viral reels, SEO, and growth hacks. And I almost bought into it too. Almost.

But instead of chasing big, I decided to stay small, and go deep.

When I started my newsletter, ‘Author Circle,’ I didn’t have thousands of people hanging on to every word. I had a small circle of writers and creatives who showed up, week after week. And I showed up for them.

We started talking in the comments. Then in Substack Chat. We ran writing challenges, shared our wins, and even launched our own books. They didn’t just read my newsletter, they helped shape it.

And from this small but engaged group, I’ve built a thriving business with paid subscribers, a cohort program, 1:1 clients, and digital products that actually sell.

No fancy funnels. No viral content. Just genuine connection, one person at a time.

If you’re still in the early stages of your business, I want you to hear this: a small audience isn’t a disadvantage. It’s your superpower.

And in this post, I’ll show you why.

The hidden power of small audiences.

Let’s bust the myth right here: small doesn’t mean weak. In fact, a small audience can move faster, buy sooner, and grow with you in a way a massive, passive audience never will.

Here’s why:

1. Higher trust = Higher conversion.

When someone feels like you’re talking to them, not at them, they trust you. And trust sells. Your small audience isn’t skimming, they’re listening. Engaging. Replying. Asking questions. They feel seen. That’s a much easier place to offer your first product, test a service, or build a paid tier.

2. Lower pressure, more freedom.

When you’re not performing for the crowd, you’re free to experiment.
Try a messy launch. Test a weird product idea. Share an unpolished story.
Small lets you test the edges without the fear of backlash or brand damage. It’s your creative lab.

3. Real conversations, not broadcasts.

You can reply to every email. Say hi to every new subscriber. Ask them what they need.
You’re not shouting into the void. You’re talking to humans.
That level of interaction becomes your insight engine, you’ll know exactly what to create because they’ll tell you.

4. Tighter Feedback Loop

With a small audience, you get feedback instantly and directly.
When I tested my Notes Challenge and later my Skill Sessions, it was my core group that told me what landed, what didn’t, and what they wanted next.
Big creators guess. Small creators ask.

5. You build with them, not for them.

A small audience makes you a better business owner.
You learn how to sell, serve, and support without hiding behind ads, automations, or funnels. You develop products side-by-side with the people who will buy them. And that’s how sustainable businesses are born.

Why small is good for you (especially early on)

If you're in the early stages of building your online business, staying small isn’t just smart, it’s strategic.

Here’s why small works in your favor:

1. You’re still figuring things uut

When you're just starting out, you don’t have all the answers. You’re still experimenting with your voice, testing different content styles, refining your niche, and shaping your offer.
A small audience gives you room to evolve without a spotlight on your every move. You can make mistakes without mass scrutiny. You can pivot without panic.

2. You can be wrong (and still recover)

I’ve created digital products that didn’t sell. I’ve written posts that flopped. I’ve run challenges that no one finished.
But because my community was small and invested, it didn’t become a disaster, it became a conversation. They told me what worked, what didn’t, and what they wanted instead. That feedback loop is gold.

3. You learn the business side fast

Selling to a small audience forces you to get good at the basics:

• Writing compelling copy

• Having real sales conversations

• Delivering value

• Asking for feedback
  These are the muscles you need before you scale. Big numbers don’t help if you don’t know how to convert them into income.

4. You avoid the “Big But Broke” trap

I’ve seen creators with thousands of followers, and no clear offer. Or worse, offers that no one buys.
Why? Because they grew wide, not deep.
A small audience, nurtured properly, is a better predictor of revenue than a big one that barely knows you.

Why small is good for them (your audience)

We often forget this part, your audience benefits more from your small size than you think.

They don’t just want your content. They want connection. And small-scale creators can offer something big names can’t: intimacy.

1. They get access to you.

In a small circle, your readers aren’t just numbers on a list. They’re names you remember, comments you reply to, and stories you engage with.
When someone hits reply on your newsletter and actually hears back from you? That’s magic. It builds trust. And trust leads to action, sign-ups, purchases, and word-of-mouth referrals.

2. It feels like a boutique experience.

People are tired of being marketed to by faceless brands and celebrity creators.
They want a space that feels personal, thoughtful, and human.
When your content speaks directly to their challenges, and they know you’re listening. it creates loyalty that big creators can’t manufacture.

3. Your Content Becomes More Relevant

When you know your readers by name (or at least by type), you naturally tailor your content.
You’re not guessing what will perform well. You’re creating from real conversations, emails, comments, and questions.
That kind of relevance leads to more engagement, and more sales.

4. You involve them in the process

Your audience doesn’t want to be spectators. They want to be part of your journey.
Let them vote on your next product idea. Share behind-the-scenes decisions. Invite them to test something before it launches.
It makes them feel valued, and turns them into advocates.

Be the creator who went small and won.

I know it’s tempting to chase big numbers.

We see the screenshots of 10K subscribers, six-figure launches, and viral growth hacks. And we think, If I’m not growing fast, I must be doing something wrong.

But what if the opposite is true?

What if staying small, on purpose, is the most powerful move you can make—especially in the early stages of your business?

When I stopped chasing big and started nurturing real relationships with my small audience, everything shifted. I launched offers that sold. Ran cohorts that filled. Created products people actually wanted, because I knew them. And they knew me.

Growth didn’t happen through scale. It happened through service.

So if you’re sitting there with 50 or 500 subscribers, wondering if it’s enough, it is.
You don’t need more followers. You need more connection. More listening. More care.

Small audiences buy faster because small audiences trust faster.

Lean in. Show up. Go deep.

That’s where the magic starts happening.

---

That’s all from me today.

As always, thanks for reading.